[davemonfl]

I'm thinking about trimming down the number of cars I have and wondering if anyone has experience driving both a Cayman and a 335i. I currently own too many cars - a 2007 Cayman with 5sp MT, a 2009 VW Jetta GLI 2.0T with 6sp MT, and a Hyundai SUV to pull a trailer full of band equipment to our gigs on the weekends. Obviously paying insurance and maintenance on 3 cars is not fun.

I need to keep the SUV for the band but I'm considering one of two things:

Sell off the Jetta and the Cayman and buy a 335i to replace the two.
or
Sell off the Jetta and buy a 328i and keep the Cayman

It would be nice to cut down on my insurance bill, but I am not sure if the 335i would be as much fun as the Cayman....any opinions from folks that have driven both?

I'm also worried that the 335i would be too unreliable, both the Jetta and the Porsche have been pretty reliable. Any opinions would be appreciated!