I test drove multiple Granturismo's with the 4.7 last year, lots to like. Sounds fantastic from the factory, loved the auto trans, looks to kill but I couldn't find a comfortable seating position. I'm on the taller side but it wasn't due to lack of legroom and the infotainment does suck. Really wanted to love it but there wasn't enough to pull me in.
My vote goes for the Evora but you won't find a S2 for <$60k. Other than a 997 GT3 it's my favorite sports car new/used <$125k. The S1 is amazing but the high door sill makes getting in/out a PITA and a deal breaker, at least for me. Otherwise, it's perfect in every way. I have yet to drive a car with steering feel as good as an Evora.
I'll throw a few suggestions out there...
-B8 RS5 with the N/A V8 - obviously not as special as a GT-S, DB9 or Evora but a fantastic GT cruiser that makes great noises (downshifts are
), quality interior, comfortable, and well below your budget
-CTS V coupe? Never driven one but the coupes are rare, basically a luxurious 2+2 Corvette
-High mileage GTR? Would be too beat up at this price point?