[theredwrx]

This is my first post, but I have been on this forum reading for a few months now. I've learned a lot, so thanks!

So here is my question for you. I really want a 2009 E90 but am having difficulty justifying spending $43+ on a car at this stage of my life.

I drive a 2002 WRX which I love, but I need something more "grown up." I want a BMW, and that's about it, but the 230 HP the 328i has doesn't really do anything for me. (On paper...I have yet to test drive any of these.) But for the same price, I can get a G35S with 300 HP.

IF you HAD to choose between a 328i or G35S...which would you pick. I know neither compares to the 335i, but let's keep that to a different post. Both have to be a manual and will keep to minimal options just because I don't really need / want most of them. The sports package on the BMW is mandatory for me.

Thanks in advance for the advice!