[wcbmw]

"proper seat posture"? WOW

[teaston]

I’m in the same position deciding between comfort seats and sports seats. I’d definitely spec memory and lumbar support so price is virtually no different (£45), but these opinions of the comfort seats being uncomfortable and not hugging you in is a bit worrying!

So, final answer, which is best?

[FMIB]

I don't think there is a final answer. End of the day its personal preference on what you find most comfortable. In my opinion, if you are from the wider generation, the comfort seats are a safer and potentially a more comfortable option. The side bolsters still squeeze you when you select sport mode

[SoCal540]

Originally Posted by FMIB

I don't think there is a final answer. End of the day its personal preference on what you find most comfortable. In my opinion, if you are from the wider generation, the comfort seats are a safer and potentially a more comfortable option. The side bolsters still squeeze you when you select sport mode

IMO, I really don't think there is much of a debate here... the multi contour seats are the one must have option. Again, just my 2 cents but there are far too many complaints regarding the "sport seats" whether you are skinny, fit, or heavy. I've had multi contour seats on every BMW since 2006 and I'm convinced other than maybe a Volvo or something super luxury well over $100k these are the best seats available and worth every penny.

[mobilejo]

Originally Posted by SoCal540

IMO, I really don't think there is much of a debate here.

That's debatable

I'm 6'6 and wide, and have flipped between comfort seats and sports seats in various BMW's over the years (numerous 5ers and X5s). This go round, I preferred the sports seats in the G30. They simply suited by body better, and I feel more 'in' them than 'on' them.

Obviously lumbar support is a must, but with sport seats now having adjustable side bolsters on the back rest, and deeper bolsters than comfort seats on the seat base, they are better for me. I can sit in my seats all day in comfort.

So the only thing which is not debatable is that its a highly subjective area and its impossible to know what will be more comfortable for someone else.

[SoCal540]

Originally Posted by mobilejo

That's debatable

I'm 6'6 and wide, and have flipped between comfort seats and sports seats in various BMW's over the years (numerous 5ers and X5s). This go round, I preferred the sports seats in the G30. They simply suited by body better, and I feel more 'in' them than 'on' them.

Obviously lumbar support is a must, but with sport seats now having adjustable side bolsters on the back rest, and deeper bolsters than comfort seats on the seat base, they are better for me. I can sit in my seats all day in comfort.

So the only thing which is not debatable is that its a highly subjective area and its impossible to know what will be more comfortable for someone else.

I agree everyone is different but I have seen numerous complaints regarding the sport seats being uncomfortable if not painful to sit in and few if any on the multi contour seats so be very careful before you choose because you'll be stuck with your decision. Good luck!

[teaston]

Originally Posted by mobilejo

That's debatable

I'm 6'6 and wide, and have flipped between comfort seats and sports seats in various BMW's over the years (numerous 5ers and X5s). This go round, I preferred the sports seats in the G30. They simply suited by body better, and I feel more 'in' them than 'on' them.

Obviously lumbar support is a must, but with sport seats now having adjustable side bolsters on the back rest, and deeper bolsters than comfort seats on the seat base, they are better for me. I can sit in my seats all day in comfort.

So the only thing which is not debatable is that its a highly subjective area and its impossible to know what will be more comfortable for someone else.

I think you've hit the nail on the head, I just went into the dealers and tried both seats and no matter how I adjusted the comfort seats I always felt like I was sitting on them and not in them, whereas with a few quick adjustments the sports seats were perfect straight away!

[530iDriver]

Originally Posted by SoCal540

I agree everyone is different but I have seen numerous complaints regarding the sport seats being uncomfortable if not painful to sit in and few if any on the multi contour seats so be very careful before you choose because you'll be stuck with your decision. Good luck!

IMHO, the sports seats and they are great. Most comfortable seats I have ever had on a car. They are sofas in comparison to the standard leather seats in my old 2011 E90.

[530iDriver]

Originally Posted by teaston

I think you've hit the nail on the head, I just went into the dealers and tried both seats and no matter how I adjusted the comfort seats I always felt like I was sitting on them and not in them, whereas with a few quick adjustments the sports seats were perfect straight away!

Exactly, with the sports seats you do feel like you are sitting in them not on them.

[Crisenelu]

Originally Posted by 54Me

I haven't confirmed yet (on it's way) but what I understand is that they even automatically adjust to firm up the side bolstering when you change the car into Sport mode.

Yes when you change mode they hug you the way you adjust the side bolsters in sport is remembered for when you switch modes. It is cool and usefull.

[mobilejo]

Originally Posted by SoCal540

I agree everyone is different but I have seen numerous complaints regarding the sport seats being uncomfortable if not painful to sit in and few if any on the multi contour seats so be very careful before you choose because you'll be stuck with your decision. Good luck!

I've seen a LOT of complaints about both types - there is a whole thread on 'another popular 5 series forum' complaining about the comfort seats being uncomfortable. And of course the same exists re: sports seats.

Thats why you HAVE to try both, and why the issue is debatable.

[teaston]

Originally Posted by mobilejo

I've seen a LOT of complaints about both types - there is a whole thread on 'another popular 5 series forum' complaining about the comfort seats being uncomfortable. And of course the same exists re: sports seats.

Thats why you HAVE to try both, and why the issue is debatable.

Definitely a good idea to try both, from my testing I think the comfort seats are for the ‘larger’ person! I’m quite slim so the sport seats fit me like a glove.

[ibk11]

I took a bit of a leap of faith with my order, opting for Nappa comfort seats without trying out either of them in person (!). Haven't even seen a picture of them.

I'm quite used to sport seats from my M3 but figured the character of the G30 is not really as targeted towards sliding sideways around corners etc. I'm fairly slim, kinda bony so I was hoping for a bit more padding from the comfort seat

The only reason I went for Nappa is, the Dakota stuff felt like such a big downgrade after Merino on our last car, it was the first thing the missus commented on when we did the test drive. Merino was great but a little fragile - any rivets on your Levis or whatever can scuff the leather pretty badly.

[teaston]

Originally Posted by ibk11

I took a bit of a leap of faith with my order, opting for Nappa comfort seats without trying out either of them in person (!). Haven't even seen a picture of them.

I'm quite used to sport seats from my M3 but figured the character of the G30 is not really as targeted towards sliding sideways around corners etc. I'm fairly slim, kinda bony so I was hoping for a bit more padding from the comfort seat

The only reason I went for Nappa is, the Dakota stuff felt like such a big downgrade after Merino on our last car, it was the first thing the missus commented on when we did the test drive. Merino was great but a little fragile - any rivets on your Levis or whatever can scuff the leather pretty badly.

I can’t tell the difference between Nappa & Merino, I swear they’re the same thing with different price tags!